There have been two Johnny Mathis’ in music since the 1950’s, they had some things in common early on. Then one would eventually become known as a pop icon and the other became a prolific songwriter in Country Music.
At one time during the 1980’s, Aubrey Mayhew, producer of many Country Johnny Mathis recordings, had the idea to record an album with both Country Johnny Mathis and Johnny Mathis, the iconic pop singer. It would have been titled, ‘Johnny Mathis Meet Johnny Mathis’. Those details for recording were never worked out and the album never came to be.
The paths of the two Johnny Mathis’ did not cross in person but they both shared a lot of similarities in life and career.
Country Johnny Mathis was born in Maud, Texas on September 28, 1930 while Johnny Mathis was born on September 30, 1935 in Gilmer, Texas in Upshur County. Both share the same birth month of September, both were born in the same state of Texas and the cities that they were born in were only 64 miles apart, 2 counties away from each other. (Country Johnny Mathis was the 4th child of his parents 6 children, Johnny Mathis was also the 4th child of his parents 7 children.)
Country Johnny Mathis would record his first solo recording in 1948 and one of his first notable cuts was by Faron Young in 1951 (“You’re Just Imagination). By the early 50’s, he was a regular performer on the Louisiana Hayride in Shreveport, Louisiana and releasing recordings nationally.
Pop music’s Johnny Mathis would make his first studio recording in 1956, ‘Johnny Mathis – A New Sound In Popular Song’ on Columbia Records.
By 1954, Country Johnny Mathis teamed up with Jimmy Lee Fautheree to record “If You Don’t Somebody Else Will” (Chess Records). This would be Johnny’s first chart debut as an artist as the single went Top 5, peaking at #3 on the Billboard Country and Western chart, leading to the duo’s 1954 nomination by disc jockeys for ‘Most Promising Country and Western Artist’ (other artists nominated that year included Faron Young and Elvis Presley.) That chart hit, along with Elvis Presley’s first hit (“That’s All Right Mama”) had the two acts touring together in 1955.
Johnny Mathis landed his first charting single in 1957 with “Wonderful, Wonderful”, which became a Top 20 song going to #7 on the Billboard Hot 100, #23 on the R&B chart and #2 on Easy Listening. This would start a string of pop chart hits as an artist for Johnny Mathis. By the end of the 50’s, the management of the pop Johnny Mathis had reached out and offered Country Johnny Mathis a certain amount of money if he would change his name. The Country performer and songwriter declined and this is where he added “Country” in front of his name.
From here the career paths of the two entertainers would take their respective turns. Country Johnny Mathis would enjoy another chart song or two as an artist but he became known as a prolific songwriter in Country Music with songs eventually recorded by 12 Country Music Hall of Fame Inductees and receiving two BMI Citations of Achievement. (George Jones alone recorded over 20 of his songs.) Johnny’s classic country recordings are still being used in film, TV and commercials today.
Johnny Mathis would go on to popularity as a pop artist icon with a string major hits such as “Chances Are” #1 in 1957 and “Too Much, Too Little, Too Late” (#1 in 1978) along with Christmas recordings that remain popular to this day during the Christmas season. (One interesting note of difference between the two Mathis’, Country Johnny Mathis never recorded or wrote a Christmas song.)
The two artists continued on their career paths in the 50’s and beyond, one becoming a prolific songwriter in Country Music and the other becoming an icon in Pop Music.
Listen to Country Johnny Mathis on Spotify.
Listen to Johnny Mathis on Spotify.